A serious post today
I have been thinking a lot recently. We Ang-Moh educated, Chinese-brought-up Asian kids have it tough dont we?
There is this constant struggle between our desire for independence, autonomy, the ability to chart our own course and be free to thrive in the great wide Western world etc…and our obligations as Chinese children, to obey and honour our elders, deferring to their wishes, putting them first, taking care of them in their old age etc etc
I like livng in Australia, love my lifestyle, love the education and healthcare system here…but always at the back of my mind I think about my ageing parents…who will keep them company when all their kids are so far away? Who will bring them to yumcha on weekends? Who will bring them to the dr when they are sick? Who will look after them, bring them water, boil porridge for them when they are laid up in bed? Who will drive them around when they are unable to drive? Who will one day wipe their bums when their arms are wasted away from old age and from infirmity?
I think about this a lot when I look after Abby’s needs, when i cook for her, feed her, wipe her bum, dress her…I think about how much love I was shown by my parents when I was her age, unable to care for myself. One day, they too will be unable to care for themselves. Do I REALLY want to relegate the care of my parents to Indonesian maids?
These are the people who cared for me and nurtured me when i was growing up…who gave me everything they had to give…who sacrificed themselves and their wants and desires, sometimes their needs even, to help me fulfill my ambitions
They made me who I am today.
Can I really pat-pat my bum and say “Thanks mum and dad, see ya! Tell the maid to bring you water if you cant walk to the kitchen, and call an ambulance if you need to see a dr”
I know what I want, what my husband wants, what is best for my child(ren). But can I REALLY leave my parents like that, leave them behind, leave them to the mercies of paid employees who have neither love nor duty towards them?
In a sense, people who have siblings who are willing and able to take up this responsibility are lucky cause they never have to resolve this question. But for those people with no siblings, or when neither you nor any of your siblings are able to take care of your parents, where does the buck stop? The oldest? The son? The one with the most understanding spouse? Where does the buck stop?
Somebody told me last night that these weighty issues can threaten to drown a person even before they learn to swim (in the sea of life, so to speak)
Is it wrong to defer your responsibilities as a Chinese child until you are financially stable, career established? Is that wrong? No, i cant see anything wrong with that. But i remember a poem I learned in Primary School “Zi Yu Yang Er Qin Bu Zai” - It was a poem of deepest regret, literally, the son wants to serve and take care of the parents, but they are no longer around to be served and taken care of.
Defer is not wrong, but for how long? Wait to have enough money first…but how much is enough money? I know (because I’m in this situation myself) that there will always be competing priorities - food? petrol? Extracting wisdom teeth? Baby’s winter gear? A bigger house with a yard for the kids to run in? School fees? Life insurance? - and the dilemma is worse once you have a child.
Do you give the best to your child and leave the scraps for your parents? Do you give your best to your parents and leave the scraps for your child? Do you give half half and satisfy none? What is the right thing to do?
I have also been thinking about this…what do you do when your Western-trained brain (and your Western values-dominated religion) tells you one way is right, but your Chinese-trained values tell you otherwise?
Do you follow your brain, be logical and wise, even sometimes to the point of being heartless, and do what you have been educated to believe is right…even though it causes your parents severe heartache? Or do you bend your will to the people you love, and sacrifice your desires to fulfill theirs, because that’s the only way they will ever understand that you love and honour them?
What IS the Chinese way?
I did a paper in Negotiationn which touched a bit on this… traditionally we place ultimate importance on the Confucian values of li, yi, lian, chi (respect, loyalty, modesty, filial piety) and most of all xiao (obedience and honour to one’s elders)…asserting one’s wishes and desires in defiance of the wishes and desires of one’s parents is wrong and immoral.
Obviously that is the strict traditional view…nowadays no one really follows that anymore…everyone expects a bit of give. The problem and eternal struggle we face is, how much give is acceptable, and when would you cross the line into bu xiao?
I am struggling a bit today. I miss my parents. And mum has not been well recently.
You know, it kills me sometimes to know that I am a doctor, the first in my family, lovingly brought up and cultivated with every skill and ability possible, lovingly sent abroad to learn what I needed to learn, lovingly given the freedom to live where I want to live…and my own mum has to depend on other people’s goodwill and kindness and professional expertise when she is unwell.
What is my responsibility? What are my duties? Wife, mother, sister, daughter…which has to come first?